Skip to content

Fine Accoutrements Aquamarine

Listen to this article

I recently tried some Fine Accoutrements (FA) Aquamarine shave soap and aftershave splash, a “relaxing green-aquatic fragrance developed in collaboration with West Coast Shaving.”

Sharpologist has covered Fine Accoutrements products before, including American Blend and Italian Citrus.  FA offered to send me a sample of the Aquamarine shave soap and aftershave splash: their soaps generally have an excellent reputation so I was curious to see if the their collaboration with West Coast Shaving would change the end product in some way.

Fine Accoutrements Aquamarine Shave Soap

From the Fine Accoutrements website:

Aquamarine evokes the carefree feeling of relaxing sea-side, under a warm sun, accompanied only by the rhythmic sound of the surf.

Notes: lemon, sweet orange, rosemary, algae, oakmoss, driftwood, amber, musk

About the soap base:

Mr. Fine has famously sourced the same renowned soap base used by the long time European lather-kings, Tabac and Irish Moos, for his own Classic Shaving Soap. Utilizing an expensive and labor intensive process, the soap is triple-milled, or pressed at least three times to remove all unnecessary water weight, before being shaped and stamped with a vintage extrusion machine. This extra care results in an exceptionally consistent lather and many more shaves per ounce than can be expected from soft soaps.

Ingredients: Potassium Stearate, Sodium Stearate, Potassium Tallowate, Aqua, Potassium Cocoate, Sodium Tallowate, Fragrance, Sodium Cocoate, Glycerine, Potassium Hydroxide, Tetrasodium EDTA, Tetrasodium Etidronate, Sodium Hydroxide

My Experience With Fine Aquamarine Shave Soap

As with all FA soaps it is triple-milled and there is an image of Mr. Fine stamped onto the soap puck.

The scent is a little muddled for me.  I get predominantly generic citrus notes with some underlying wood notes, and I’m not able to pick out individual elements.  But remember I have a pretty insensitive nose so don’t take that as gospel.  In any event it’s a pleasant, moderately-strong scent from the puck to me, softening a little when on my face.

Like other FA shave soaps, I find lathering Aquamarine easy and fairly tolerant of water ratio (even in my hard water).  The lather is a little softer-looking compared to some other soaps (say, meringue vs. yogurt).

But where the rubber meets the road is shave performance.  Does Aquamarine shave differently than other FA shave soaps?

I think it compares quite competitively: excellent glide/lubrication and very good protection/cushion.  I do get the occasional “weeper” with it but I think the performance is on-par with other similarly-priced shave soaps.

Aquamarine Aftershave Splash

Right up front let me say I’m not a big fan of alcohol-based aftershave splashes–I much prefer balms or gels.  But I will also grudgingly admit that I kind of like FA’s Aquamarine splash.  The scent is, if not identical, complementary to the shave soap.  I get the Aquamarine vibe under an alcohol base.

Ingredients (INCI*): Alcohol Denat., Water (Aqua), Fragrance (Parfum), Isopropyl Alcohol, Menthol.

As you might expect I get some “burn” from this splash but it’s not overwhelming.


Fine Accoutrements Aquamarine is a fine addition to the line, though I think some of their other scents will continue to overshadow this one.

Aquamarine is currently out of stock at West Coast Shaving but it is still available at Fine Accoutrements website.

Have you tried Fine Accoutrements Aquamarine?  What do you think of it?  Leave a comment below!


Shave tutor and co-founder of sharpologist. Also check out my content on Youtube, Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest!View Author posts

4 thoughts on “Fine Accoutrements Aquamarine”

  1. Martin Sobkowiak

    I tried Aquamarine After Shave and it is not holding up to the hype around it. After all it replaces Fresh Vetiver and that is a mistake, taking Fresh Vetiver of the product line, it was their best.
    The Aquamarine (AM) is very burning, mostly due to the alcohol. I am missing the cooling effects and the freshness from the menthol, that is definitely disappointing that the initial burn is not ending in the cooling that the other originals have ( even last year’s Italian Citrus had it [I have not bought it this year, I DID buy American Blend and it is not the same, they must have changed something in the mix]).
    The first scent impression of mandarin orange PEEL is a bit irritating, I like Mandarin Orange scent but the peel scent is different (the bitter notes from the peel). Good it disappeared soon. The scent is somewhere settling close to Yves Staint Laurent’ s JAZZ which was my favorite in the 80s. So THAT allows me to give it 3 1/2 out if 5. It is definitely NOT an After Shave to replace Fresh Vetiver; it lacks the cooling and the freshness, I prefer alcohol based over balms, if they end in a cooling experience on the skin…

  2. my uncle Nunzio was a barber back in the 40s til the day he passed away in the 90s. he would cut his alcohol based after shaves with witch hazel as it was less stinging but still worked well. of course he had full strength for those who wanted it. I liked the stuff diluted when he cut my hair and back of neck. I was too young to get a shave from him but oh how I wish I could now.

  3. Thank you for the review of Fine Aquamarine. I’ve been trying to not purchase software of late because I have so much I haven’t used yet but I like the scent description so this is on my radar.

Comments are closed.