If you’ve ever wondered why some shaving creams feel smooth while others burn or dry out your skin, you’re not alone. We used a wide range of popular shave creams with different application methods and across different beard types to see which ones actually deliver a closer, more comfortable shave. Whether you prefer traditional wet shaving or just want fewer nicks and irritation, here are the products that stood out…and why.
Takeaway Summary: Best Shaving Creams by Use Case and Availability
Best shaving creams are not interchangeable. Performance depends on skin type, beard thickness, and how well a product maintains glide and hydration during the shave. These are the best shaving creams we’ve tested, grouped by real-world use case and availability.
Start with your usual shaving routine. These recommendations consider how easily each cream works with your preferred method.
[Editor’s note: Amazon links are Sharpologist affiliate links. Geni.us links may be affiliate.]
If You Apply Cream By Hand
These picks prioritize straightforward coverage, comfortable shaving performance, and value at the amount needed for hand application. Traditional brush-lathering creams can also be applied by hand, though you will generally need more cream and may need a wetter hand and face for best coverage.
- Best starting point: Cremo. Cremo combines very good lubrication, forgiving hand application, and broad availability. It’s a practical starting point if you want an easy-to-use shaving cream you can find in many local stores. Read our Cremo evaluation.
- Best value: Barbasol 1919. Its low price, excellent glide and cushion, and small amount needed per shave make it the value pick for hand application. Local availability is limited, but it is available online. Read more.
- Fragrance-free option: Pacific Shaving Unscented Clean Shave Cream. For readers who prefer to avoid added fragrance but still want a comparatively inexpensive product that performs well even when applied by hand. Click for more details.
If You Use A Shaving Brush
These picks prioritize easy lather building, useful coverage across passes, and value when worked with a brush.
- Best starting point: Supply’s Ultra Lather Shave Cream. Available in several scents, this shaving cream is very tolerant of a wide range of cream-to-water ratios for the beginner, and performs exceptionally well for its price. Read more.
- Versatile traditional alternative: Taylor Of Old Bond Street. One of the three old-school, traditional British premium shave cream brands, “TOBS” is well known for its performance, range of scents, and relative value among its peers. Read our TOBS evaluation.
- Fragrance-free option: The Art Of Shaving Unscented. For readers who prefer to avoid added fragrance but still want very good performance when used with a brush. Check out more details.
How These Recommendations Were Chosen
Sharpologist specializes in getting the best, most enjoyable shave possible.
I have personally used every product included in this article. These recommendations draw on my own shaving experience, feedback from Sharpologist contributors and readers who have used the products, and more than 15 years of research into shaving creams, reviews, and specialty shaving discussions. The focus here is shaving facial hair.
When evaluating a cream, I consider how smoothly the razor glides, the cushion it provides, how easily it produces useful coverage, and how my skin feels after rinsing. Fragrance, the amount needed per shave, price and availability also influence whether I recommend it for a particular routine.
The quick recommendations reflect those practical differences. For hand application, I emphasize straightforward coverage and value at the amount of cream needed. For brush use, I emphasize easy lather building and useful coverage across passes. Traditional lathering creams can also be applied by hand, generally with more product and a wetter hand and face. The detailed evaluations explain why each cream earns its place and the tradeoffs to consider.
Looking for the best shaving soaps? Click/tap here for that article.
Our Recommended Shaving Creams
These are my recommended shaving creams for men, with particular attention to how they perform with a safety razor (for a deep dive into the Best Safety Razor read our guide). Some are designed to be lathered with a shaving brush, though they can be used brushless as well (you just have to use more of the product).
Cremo Shaving Cream Products
Cremo earns our recommendation for hand application because it lubricates the skin very well and tolerates variation in the amount of water on your face. That combination makes it easier to get useful coverage without carefully balancing the cream and water. Application ease and glide are the main reasons it is our starting recommendation for readers who shave without a brush.
Cremo is available in several scents, along with a “Sensitive Skin” version that the company describes as containing no synthetic fragrance (that version contains essential oils, so it is not a “fragrance-free option”). The “Refreshing” version with peppermint, menthol and tea tree oil is one I particularly enjoy in summer. Choose the version according to your fragrance and cooling preferences.
Availability is another practical advantage. Many national drugstore chains, grocery stores and big-box retailers carry Cremo, and it is also available online.
Purchase options: Cremo shaving cream.
Barbasol 1919
Barbasol 1919 delivers excellent shaving performance. Lubrication and glide are exceptional, and cushion and protection are excellent, particularly considering how little cream you need to use. Post-shave moisturization is good as well.
At about $6 for 6 ounces, the combination of a low purchase price, strong performance and a small amount needed per shave makes Barbasol 1919 our best-value recommendation for hand application.
Although most Barbasol consumer products are widely available in the U.S., 1919 is stocked in fewer local stores. It is also available online, including through Amazon.
Pacific Shaving Unscented
Our reviewers consistently commented that the lubrication and cushion of the Unscented are comparable to those of higher-priced products, with or without a brush. Pacific Shaving is well known for their “good for the skin, good for the wallet, good for the Earth” philosophy. I’m a big fan of their lineup (particularly their Caffeinated line) and their products perform consistently well.
Available from the Pacific Shaving website and Amazon.
Supply
Supply’s Ultra Lather Shave Cream is available in several relatively mild scents. Building a lather with this shave cream using a brush is stupid-easy, even in “hard” water. It is also quite tolerant of the water-to-cream ratio. It can work brushless so consider this shave cream “brush friendly” but not a “brush required” product.
Lubrication/glide is very good and the protection/cushion aspect is outstanding! The main practical drawback is online-only distribution.
Taylor Of Old Bond Street
Taylor of Old Bond Street – “TOBS” has a wide variety of both classic and modern scents and some versions are formulated specifically for sensitive skin. TOBS shave creams are well known for not only their solid shaving performance, but also their lower price-point among premium brands, and were mentioned with positive comments very often by our reviewers. Their Sandalwood shave cream is often listed as a favorite shaving cream on Amazon. Unlike the Supply shave cream, TOBS is available both online and at some high-end brick-and-mortar retailers.
The Art Of Shaving
The Art of Shaving – While The Art Of Shaving-branded “brick and mortar” stores closed a few years ago, the line is still available at many mall retailers such as Bloomingdales, Nordstrom, and Macy’s, as well as online.
While the line-up includes an unscented version made for those with sensitive skin, they have fragranced shave creams for almost any preference. Other reviewers and I consider The Art of Shaving creams strong performers in both lubrication and cushion. Their fairly wide availability online makes them a “gateway drug” into good shaving.
Other Shaving Creams Worth Considering
Castle Forbes
Castle Forbes shaving creams have a reputation of being strongly-scented: I like to say that using their Limes shave cream is like getting hit in the face with a key lime pie. Without a doubt a luxurious product with outstanding performance (at a commensurate price).
St. James Of London
Another British brand now in the US. I like to refer to St. James of London shave cream scents as “traditional with a twist” with scents like Mandarin & Patchouli, Cedarwood & Clarysage, Black Pepper & Lime, Sandalwood & Bergamot, etc. They also boast an “all natural” and nourishing ingredient mix. Performance is excellent across the line.
Taconic Shave
Taconic Shave has a line of shave creams in a pump bottle that performs especially well: its “looser” consistency compared to other creams on this list tends to make it more suited to hand-application, while still being brush-friendly too. It’s quite slick, if you’re looking for something especially lubricating. Taconic shave creams are also an exceptional value. They are made in small batches by a knowledgeable artisan.
Truefitt & Hill
Truefitt & Hill shave creams are a good mix of “natural” and cologne-like scents, some popular with younger men (1805, Ultimate Comfort) while others are more classic (Trafalgar and Grafton are considered by some as “old man” scents). The No. 10 cream is meant to be used brushless but is also “brush friendly.” Truefitt and Hill creams may be ever-so-slightly less cushioning than others in this category but the difference is subtle: most Sharpologist commenters agree the performance is excellent.
Trumper
Trumper shave cream scents tend to stay in the classic, conservative realm. Some may seem a bit foppish but you might be surprised how downright masculine a Rose or a Violet scent can smell. Another one of the long-established British grooming brands, they have a long-established, solid reputation among Anglophiles, traditional shave enthusiasts (myself included), and modern product reviewers as consistent in their performance.
Pacific Shaving Caffeinated
Pacific Shaving was originally known for their Shaving Oil. They later added several shaving creams. Along with their fragrance free option is their Caffeinated Shaving Cream. Although promoted as a “brushless” shave cream it is “brush friendly” and many (including me) report the performance of Pacific Shaving Caffeinated improves even more when lathered with a brush. Pacific Shaving is also notable for their use of natural ingredients. “Brick and mortar” distribution is available at Hy-Vee, Savemart, Giant Eagle, Big Y, and some Stop & Shop stores, in addition to online distribution.
Proraso Lather Shave Cream
If you happen to find a Proraso shaving cream in a local brick and mortar store (sometimes seen in stores that specialize in over-stocks or inventory of “distressed” businesses–TJ Maxx, TK Maxx, Marshalls, etc.), snatch one up. Proraso is very good!
Available in a number of scents/formulations, you will probably most commonly find the “Refreshing And Toning” cooling shave cream, with eucalyptus oil and menthol, in the green tube. But all Proraso shave creams are comparatively inexpensive, widely-known and well-thought-of in the traditional shaving community, and perform very well.
How To Choose A Shave Cream
Start with how you normally apply shaving cream–by hand or with a brush– then consider performance, fragrance and value.
Look For The Performance You Want
Glide describes how smoothly the razor moves across your skin. Cushion describes the protective layer the cream provides during a pass. Coverage and post-shave feel matter too: how well the cream spreads, how it remains useful during the shave, and how your skin feels after rinsing.
Look at those observations in the product descriptions. For example, Barbasol 1919 earns its recommendation through strong glide and cushion at a low price. Supply’s forgiving water-to-cream ratio makes it an approachable choice for building lather with a brush. Choose according to the qualities that matter most in your routine.
Choose Your Fragrance And Cooling Preferences
Scent is part of the shaving experience, but preferences vary. You may enjoy a traditional sandalwood fragrance, prefer a mild scent, or want to avoid added fragrance altogether. If fragranced products have bothered your skin before, the fragrance-free recommendations offer a starting point.
For more options and an explanation of the labeling differences, see our guide to fragrance-free and unscented shaving creams.
Cooling is another preference. A menthol version can feel quite different from another cream in the same product line. Check the specific formulation before purchasing; a recommendation for a brand does not mean every version provides the same experience.
How Much Shaving Cream Should I Use?
Brushless creams applied by hand use a relatively small amount of product: Cremo suggests an amount about the size of an almond; Barbasol 1919 suggests an amount about the size of a nickel coin. In practice the amount should be adjusted (more or less) based on how well the skin is prepared: the goal is an even, slippery layer on wet skin.
Applying a traditional cream with a brush also uses a relatively small amount of product–they are usually quite concentrated. As a starting point, wet the brush well then gently squeeze out most of the water. Apply just enough cream to cover the tips of the brush’s bristles then build lather in a bowl or directly on the face.
If you’re applying traditional cream by hand instead of a brush, you will need to use more product with a wetter hand onto wetter skin.
Compare Value For Your Routine
Consider the price, package size and amount needed per shave together. Price per ounce provides a starting comparison, but it doesn’t account for differences in the amount needed for best performance.
Traditional lathering creams generally require more product when applied by hand, which can change their value for your routine. A low-priced cream that performs well may be all you need. A more expensive option may still appeal because of its application, scent or post-shave feel. Pay for qualities you will appreciate.
Summing Up
In conclusion, the best men’s shaving cream in 2026 is a product that caters to individual needs, provides a comfortable shave, and offers lasting results. The right cream can help make the morning ritual more enjoyable while delivering soft, smooth skin. With so many products on the market today, it’s important to do your research and pick the one that’s right for you. Don’t hesitate to try out different formulas or read customer reviews before making a purchase.
Did I miss something? Disagree with a recommendation? Leave your suggestions and comments below!
(Find this article useful? Please share it!)
