Mantic59’s Razor Blade Search: Astra (Green Box)

astra box

As I have mentioned previously (links at the bottom of this article), I have been trying different brands of razor blades in an attempt to find a suitable replacement(s) for the blade I had been using and had been discontinued.  Here are my comments on the Astra blade (green box).

Astra Green

I am making a distinction here between the blades that come in a green box vs. the blades that come in a blue box.  I found these “green” blades did not work very well for me.  Using three different Astra blades in three different razors (a Merkur Progress, a Parker 92R, and a Merkur HD) yielded the same results: numerious small nicks on the skin and a relatively short blade life.  Here is the edge of a new Astra blade as seen through a scanning electron microscope (SEM), with the blade edge at the top of the picture:

astra unused

And here is a blade after four shaves (again, with the edge at the top of the image):

astra used

You can see the edge degradation quite clearly.  But out of curiousity I cranked up the magnification of the SEM for a closer look (blade edge at top of image):

astra used 3kx mag

This particular blade is just not for me.

Thanks to John at West Coast Shaving for his help with this series of articles.

Related Posts:

Mantic59’s Blade Search Begins

Blade Search: Crystal


mantic59 mantic59 (545 Posts)

also known as "Mantic59." Shave tutor and sharpologist.

Sign up for the Sharpologist email newsletter and get tips, discounts, news, and our FREE 46 page ebook on how to enjoy your shave!


  1. I’ve come accross 2 different packages of the astra green one package was horrible quality worst bladesi’ve ever used and the other were fantastic. I think there are fakes going around with terrible quality

  2. I have never understood all the raves about the green Astra SPs. They don’t work for me at all.

Speak Your Mind