Mantic59′s Razor Blade Search: Derby

derby

I am still searching for my new “go to” razor blade.  Having previously tried Crystal, Astra, and Dorco blades, this time I look at Derby.  Derby blades are made in Turkey but are widely available.

Derby, What Have You Done?!

Derby has been my #2 “go to” blade for years and coincidentally, like my Israeli Personna “blue label” blades, ran low at about the same time.  No problem, I thought, I’ll get get another bulk pack.  But having seen quite a few reviews (mostly on the shaving forums) that Derby’s are now not as good as they used to be, I decided that I should get a smaller pack and try them as if I had never used them before.

That turned out to be a good decision.  Derby, what have you done to yourselves?!?

The Derby blades I was accustomed to were sharp, consistant, reasonably forgiving, and reliable.  They must have changed their manufacturing tolerances because I now find them much less sharp and not nearly as reliable.  All the razors I tried them in (Merkur HD, Parker 92R, Merkur Progress) resulted in ingrown hairs and generally poorer shaves.  Examination under a scanning electron microscope (SEM) was inconclusive.

Here’s an unused blade:

derby unused

 

Here’s a used blade:

derby used

The “softness” of the focus comes from whatever non-stick coating is being used.  It’s interesting that the coating remains pretty intact on the used blade.  And the blade edge isn’t chipped.  But something has clearly changed from Derby blades from a few years ago.  I’ve found an unused “old” example and plan to compare it to a “new” example by looking at the blade edge-on: I’ll immerse them in liquid nitrogen then snap them in half for a clean cross-section.  Stay tuned….

Special thanks to John at West Coast Shaving for his help with this series.

mantic59 mantic59 (539 Posts)

also known as "Mantic59." Shave tutor and sharpologist.


Sign up for the Sharpologist email newsletter and get tips, discounts, news, and our FREE 46 page ebook on how to enjoy your shave!

Comments

  1. Derby’s are the favorite of the friend who introduced me to wet shaving, but I can’t understand what he sees in them. I switched them out before finishing the first pass. It’s interesting to read that other, more experienced shavers have had similar experiences.

  2. I was disappointed by the quality control on these, especially after reading a good number of favorable reviews on these. I’d get a smooth shave from one and terrible nicks from the next two. Plus, they’re not sharp enough, at least not my Gillette fatboy.

  3. I fell in love with Feathers after trying a number of other offerings. And proceeded to buy a 100-blade box of Derbys by not carefully looking at the webpage I was using to order.

    I’ve hated them in every razor I have [Merkur 34C; 1960 Gillette Super Speed Flair tip; an open-comb Gillette from the ’30s; Feather, Lord] except the Edwin Jagger DE89 [smooth shaft]. It’s a great , great shave for me. To my astonishment, I also have an EJ DE89 with the lined detail, and it delivers a horrid and irritating shave. I’m a rational fellow, but there’s something to this notion of alchemy. . . .

    (PS back to Feathers, with a brick o’ Derbys sitting largely untouched)

Speak Your Mind

*