The Scents of Shaving: D.R. Harris Windsor and TOBS Jermyn Street

TOBS Jermyn Street and D.R. Harris Windsor

Long before Mantic59 and I started working together on Sharpologist, I was a newbie wet shaver, wondering what all the hubbub was about on the message boards and forums. Not knowing where to start, I reached out to both Classic Shaving and West Coast Shaving for advice. They both sent me enough supplies to get me going, and eventually, enough to turn this hobby into a business alongside Mantic, himself.
Interestingly, I’ve found wet shaving to be a “gateway drug” of sorts, opening my eyes to finer point of men’s style and grooming. In fact, I’ve amassed a far-too-large collection of colognes throughout this journey.   

However, there’s still one scent that I smelled on day one of this journey that left me wanting more. As a shaving cream, that scent went away as soon as I washed my face. But now I got my hands on Taylor Of Old Bond Street: Jermyn Street … the cologne. And it smells just as great as a fragrance as it does a cream.

John from West Coast Shaving was kind enough to send over a bottle for review, and he also mailed me D.R. Harris Windsor, a scent I had my eye on since I caught a whiff of a tiny sample. Both fall under the category of what I’m calling shaving scents. Unlike colognes that offer a matching aftershave, for example, these fragrances are derived from soaps or creams. It’s the best of both worlds.

Jermyn Street is the more interesting of the two. Designed for sensitive skin, it contains no alcohol, which is unusual for a cologne. Fortunately, that means it last quite a long time on the skin.

If I didn’t know scent pyramid, I’d call this a tobacco fougere, although people who understand this stuff more than me smell lime, bergamot, lavender, cedar, musk and vanilla. What I do know is this relatively linear British cologne smells wonderful and is a tremendous value: $31.00 for 100ml or 3.4 ounces.

D.R. Harris’ new Windsor cologne is another bargain at $37.99 for 100ml. It opens with a sweet orange, and dries down into black pepper, patchouli and vetiver. But it smells to me like a mash up of two more expensive and sophisticated colognes: Terre D’Hermes and Cartier Declaration.

To me, I get less of TDH’s flinty, earthy smell, and thankfully, none of Declaration’s cumin note. Windsor is an excellent daytime cologne, suitable for office wear. Its longevity is fair, but at this price for such a big bottle, it’s hard to complain.

Andy Tarnoff (43 Posts)

Sometimes snarky, occasionally suspicious, usually funny (at least in his own mind), Andy uses his blog space mostly as a written catharsis for the numerous, unrelated topics swirling around in his mildly OCD head. Andy is the publisher and co-founder of OnMilwaukee.com, a digital media company he started in 1998.


Sign up for the Sharpologist email newsletter and get tips, discounts, news, and our FREE 46 page ebook on how to enjoy your shave!

Comments

  1. So weird – these are the only 2 colognes that I own!

  2. I really like Jermyn St. as a shave soap. It’s just a great modernized fougere scent, a little brighter than Houbigant’s classic Fougere Royale. I usually wear Dior’s Eau Sauvage after shaving with it, or T&H’s West Indian Limes. Windsor has that sandalwood/vetiver base to it that gives some body to its familiar Eau de Cologne top notes. I like it well enough as a cream, but I don’t think I’d wear it all day.

  3. Well… I might have to pick up some Windsor. Jermyn Street is still my favourite scent in the world.

  4. Justin says:

    Wet Shaving has been a “gateway drug” for me too!

    I guess there are worse things than being clean shaven and smelling good.

Speak Your Mind

*