Petal Pusher’s Kokum Butter Shaving Soaps

I just experienced the most satisfying shave in all my life.” That was the mantra repeated throughout my day after test driving a Classic Kokum Butter Shaving Puck that a barber friend of mine had recommended to me over a poker game one weekend. “A shave so memorable it stays with you…” he promised and boy was he right. I had dismissed his statements as gin inspired exaggeration, but something in what he said stuck; kokum butter. I didn’t know anything more than that, but a barber gave it his blessing, and I by golly I was going to check it out, so I googled “Kokum Butter Shaving Cake” and bought the first one I stumbled upon. A week later I found myself dumfounded and excited, almost stopping strangers on the street offering up my chin to be caressed and admired…I was a kokum butter believer and I was ready to spread the new gospel.

The shaving puck is by a small company out of New England called Petal Pusher Fancies. If you don’t already know of them you need to, they are creating quite a buzz in the world of male grooming and for good reason. Simply put, they have created one hell of a cream shaving puck. The ingredients are organic, vegan and printed right on the box so there is no mystery to what you are putting on your face. Kokum butter is the main and active ingredient. This unique butter comes from the fruits of the Garcinia Indica Tree in India. The fruit kernels produced by this tree yield an emollient white butter that creates an unbeatable cream, glide, and a controlled slip that I can’t find in any shaving “soaps” these days. Truth be told, most soaps on the market are not soap at all but detergent bars loaded with chemicals. These are not your glycerin melt and pour soap cakes, nor a nature boy clay based clump of earth either. This is a hearty bar of artisan, handmade shaving soap that will last forever, and aid in giving you one of the most amazing shaves of your life.

The puck is 3 inches in diameter and 1 inch in width so sadly, it will not fit in a traditional shaving scuttle. However, if a classic scuttle is your vessel of choice you can always heat the bar with hot water, cut in half, and wedge it in the bowl. I personally prefer a deep, wide mouth scuttle for I find It is much easier to build a greater amount of lather and contain it. After heating my mug under the running tap for a minute or two in preparation, I dropped the puck in, and added a little hot water. With a seasoned swirling action, a skill that is only acquired from years of using inferior products, I was soon creating a genuine cream lather.

This particular bar happened to be a deep purple in color. Sandalwood powder is used to achieve this rich aesthetic. It certainly sets a visual tone to the ritual. The second note that hits you is the scent of the bar, neroli. For those of you not familiar with this aromatic, it comes from the essential oil of the bitter orange tree. It’s nice and earthy, masculine yet meditative, a scent a chap might have found while off in an exotic part of the world working for the East India Company. I am a bay rum kind of fella by nature, this is what I always seek out, but for the sake of a more objective review I chose to try the neroli, and I am glad I did. Don’t get me wrong, I made sure to pick up their Steam-River Rum puck as well.

After I applied a hot, rich lather to my skin, and the shaving mirror was in full extension, I was in the zone. True wet shavers know the zone I speak of, and Buddhists know this zone as satori. I made a conscious decision not to reapply the cream between passes in order to test the integrity of the kokum butter in shielding the skin, as my barber claimed it would. Each pass was true and glide my blade did…amazing.

  • 10/10 Glide
  • 9/10 Scent Strength
  • 10/10 Lather Quality

A week later I stopped by the barbershop and shared my experience with my pal. He was in between customers and sitting in his chair like a guru. After an over exuberating telling of my tale both he and his partner shook my hand, patted me on the back, and welcomed me to the secret club. Kokum butter, who would have thunk?

Ingredients: [Tallow Free & Vegan] Pure Kokum Butter, Organic Mango Seed Butter, Organic Cocoa Butter, Organic Coconut Oil, Organic Avocado Oil, Organic Sweet Almond Oil, Organic Castor Oil, Pure Essential Oils & Natural Plant Extracts.

The Soaps come in four scents: Coconut, Neroli, Steam River Rum (their version of Classic Bay Rum) and Sandalwood.

Cost: $8.95

[Addendum from Mantic59: my interest was piqued from Douglas' glowing description so I got a puck of the Neroli for myself to try.  My reaction was not quite as dramatic as Douglas'--then again I admit to being kind of jaded after trying many, many shaving soaps and creams--but it's a very good product in my opinion.  Unlike Douglas' "rich lather" description, my first try with it made a (deceptively) thinner, "softer" lather in my hard water. It still gave me an excellent shave, though!  After experimenting a little I discovered that treating it like Mitchell's Wool Fat Soap improved the look of the lather considerably.  It's growing on me.]

Douglas Smythe (4 Posts)

Creator of fine male grooming products,founding member, contributing writer & editor for HowToGrowAMoustache.Com, and Co-host of the Moustache & Blade Podcast. His mission: Create greater facial awareness and spread the gospel of wet shaving across galaxies. Contact Douglas:

Sign up for the Sharpologist email newsletter and get tips, discounts, news, and our FREE 46 page ebook on how to enjoy your shave!


  1. Hi Douglas, based on your exulted review I’ve ordered a puck of soap and their live enzyme deodorant, both in Neroli fragrance. I’ve just received them and I’ve started with the deodorant first. I think you should be less enthusiastic when writing a review about a new found fragrance, because I had such high hopes about it, but I can barely stand it. Now I’m even afraid of using the puck :D

    I’m not saying it’s not working properly – I haven’t tried it yet – it’s just the smell I can’t get used to. Just my two cents…

  2. Yup, their puck is amazing! So excited about the new hard water friendly formulation! :)

  3. I just tried this tonight. This stuff is beautiful as others had said. I loaded it right from the tin it came in and decided to try lathering it directly on my face. Amazingly it lathers easy enough to just work the lather directly on your face in about 10-15 seconds.(I have hard water and the only other decent soap I could find to work was the Taconic but it was tricky stuff) Its also nice that locally made in NE by a small business owner.

  4. Christophe says:

    Hello again,
    I have recvd this new soap!
    The re formulation brings it to a proraso level easily!
    The sweetness of the edge on the skin is amazing.
    Skin feels like moisturized for the day…

  5. Christophe says:

    Hi, to be fair with the 2 guys behind those lovely sented products I have to let you they quite often come back to me via email to give updates about their products.
    The fact i (we) could not get a proper foam from their soap sincereky embarassed them.
    Last week they emailed me to tell me they reformulated their shaving soap taking into condideration my remarks, top of it, soap is being sent to me!
    Great service and much more guys.

  6. theretroshave says:

    I bought the Sandalwood puck after reading this review, and I am so glad that I did. I didn’t expect to get this kind of performance out of a non-tallow-based soap. Boy was I wrong! This soap works as well, and possibly better than any soap I’ve tried. I have also lathered this soap in both soft and hard water, and it’s truly a monster latherer. If the name puts you off, don’t let it.

  7. Bassopotamus says:

    Addendum- I have really hard water, and the reformulated soap lathers really well

  8. Bassopotamus says:

    I bought two pucks based on the strength of this review, Neroli and whatever they call their bay rum. Something in the bay run irritated my skin, but the lather was good. The neroli is awesome all around. It’s hard to rank soaps, but I prefer it to several of the artisans everyone swoons over. It hangs in a rotation with some other excellent stuff ( cellsa, Klar Kabinett, DR Harris, Razorock, ARKO, etc). It is tremendously slick and gives a consistently nice shave


  1. [...] is actually a link to a review I did for Petal Pusher Fancies Kokum Butter Shaving Puck Review    – Below is a video of a quality control test with a 3-day old piece of Kokum Butter [...]

Speak Your Mind